you are not from the states,aren't you 这句话正确吗?

问题描述:

you are not from the states,aren't you 这句话正确吗?
从网站上看到这句话,但是依照一贯的反义疑问句用法,后面不应该是肯定才对吗?这句话说错了吧?

从语法角度是病句,但口语中是否会出现就很难讲,但你还是不要用.