who is the man speaking to your father just now?who is the man spoken just now?

问题描述:

who is the man speaking to your father just now?who is the man spoken just now?
为什么第一个句子用speaking,第二个句子用的是spoken 两者的区别在哪里呢?
第二个句子是 who is the man spoken to just now

问题是第二句是错的!用不着比.除非说
who is the man spoken【to】 just now?(刚才同他说话的那个人是谁?)(那个人是听别人说话的)
比较:
who is the man speaking to your father just now?
刚才同你父亲说法的那个人是谁?(是那个人在说话)第一个句子,因为是那个人(who),在说话,主动的,所以用speaking,而第二个句子,由于是那个人(who)在听话,是被动的,所以用spoken,是这样吗?OOOOKKKKKKK !!!!! 你真棒!!