Having arrived at the earthquake-stricken area,we were led to _ the homeless people lived.A.what B.in which C.that D.whe

问题描述:

Having arrived at the earthquake-stricken area,we were led to _ the homeless people lived.A.what B.in which C.that D.where
选什么?为什么?in which不是和where等价的吗
怎么答案还不一样.....觉得都有道理,到底哪个是正确答案....

选D,在led to的后面省略了一个place,那么,这个where the homeless.实际上是一个介词to的宾语从句.如果选in which的话,前面缺少先行词place.空和后面的the homeless people lived不是做led to的宾语吗?从句的lived是不及物动词,所以不缺成分,what和that就错了,那where和in which都可以呀....你说的我有点不明白.the homeless people lived做led to的宾语。从句中的lived是不及物动词,但可以有副词where去做lived的地点状语的。想填in which 的话,必须改写成:we were led to the place/area in which the homeless people lived.还有一个问题,我在网上查了,貌似2L说的副词(where)前确实不能加介词是对的.......那where不是也就不对了..如果where用作名词的话,其前面可以有介词的。如:This includes advice that televisions should be at least two metres from where their children are sitting . 这包括以下这些建议:电视机应该离孩子坐的地方至少两米远。我才看懂,这个句子应该是地点状语从句的吧, we were led to 是被动语态,we就是lead to的宾语呀,怎么会是宾语从句we were led to 是被动语态,we就是lead这个动作的承受者;而介词to后面的成分才是介词to的宾语从句,并没有说 we were led to 是宾语从句。