你今天早上吃过饭了吗?英语怎么说?是说:“Did you have breakfast this morning?”还是:“Have you had breakfast this morning?”那在什么情况下才能用“Did you have breakfast this morning?”谢谢。

问题描述:

你今天早上吃过饭了吗?英语怎么说?
是说:“Did you have breakfast this morning?”还是:“Have you had breakfast this morning?”
那在什么情况下才能用“Did you have breakfast this morning?”
谢谢。

都是对的,但是意思有一点点区别:
Have you had breakfast this morning?
跟中国人说的“吃了吗?”一个意思,问人家是否已经吃过早饭了,重点关注是“早饭”是否吃过了.
Did you have breakfast this morning?
问的是你这个早晨是否吃了早饭(当然你还可能做了其他事情,比如晨跑?)重点问的是“早晨”你是否做了这件事情.比如侦探就可能这么问你……